Backes & Backes (609) 730-3838

Probate Litigation

Inheritance Tax Interest During Estate Litigation: The Six Percent Rule

New Jersey inheritance tax is due at death and must be paid within eight months, and after that the unpaid tax bears interest at 10% a year. Buried in the same statute, N.J.S.A. 54:35-3, is a rule I have rarely seen discussed. When “claims made upon the estate, necessary litigation or other unavoidable cause of delay” keep the estate, or a part of it, from being settled within the eight months, the rate is 6% instead, and it runs “until the cause of delay is removed.” For an estate in the middle of a Will contest, that four-point difference can be worth real money, and the rule raises questions that the litigators on both sides ought to be thinking about.

The clearest modern application is De Rosa v. Director, Division of Taxation, 28 N.J. Tax 73 (2014). A granddaughter filed a probate action three months after the decedent’s death, alleging undue influence and lack of capacity, and the parties settled at mediation about fifteen months later. The Tax Court held that the tax went unpaid “as a result of necessary litigation and other unavoidable cause of delay” and allowed interest at 6%. The same estate came back the next year, De Rosa v. Director, Division of Taxation, 28 N.J. Tax 256 (2015), and lost on a different point. The executor had computed the tax on the settlement rather than on the Will, contrary to settled law, and the court upheld a separate amnesty penalty on top of the 6% interest because he had no reasonable cause for the position. The lower rate forgives the delay, and it does nothing for a return filed on the wrong basis.

The rule is not limited to Will contests. In Estate of Frost v. Director, Division of Taxation, 22 N.J. Tax 537 (2005), the decedent’s former lawyer had taken her money, and the estate recovered $250,000 from the Lawyers’ Fund for Client Protection about thirty months after her death. The Director reduced the interest on the tax on that recovery from 10% to 6% on his own, having concluded that it was the product of necessary litigation. The estate wanted more, arguing that interest should not run on tax for money it did not yet have, and the court refused. Interest ran from eight months after death, at the reduced rate, because the statute contains no exception for late-arriving assets. In Heine v. Director, Division of Taxation, 10 N.J. Tax 435 (1989), the executors argued for 6% because they could not compute the correct tax until the Division made its own adjustments, and the court held that difficulty in computing the tax is not an unavoidable cause of delay.

For anyone litigating an estate, the first point is that 6% is still interest, and the regulations make most of it avoidable. N.J.A.C. 18:26-9.12 allows an estate to estimate and pay the tax before any assessment, and a payment made within the eight months stops interest on the amount paid. An executor holding liquid funds while a contest is pending can usually pay on the basis of the Will as it stands and leave the refund or the balance for later. That is the course I would recommend in most cases, and De Rosa is a reminder that the estimate should follow the Will, whatever settlement the parties may be discussing.

The second point is that an executor who sits on liquid funds during a contest may be personally exposed for the interest. The surcharge cases on this are old but published. In Wyckoff v. O’Neil, 71 N.J. Eq. 729 (Prerog. Ct. 1906), an executor who had ample estate funds and let the tax go unpaid was charged personally for the interest and penalties, while in In re Pettigrew’s Estate, 115 N.J. Eq. 401 (Prerog. Ct. 1934), executors who lacked the funds were not. No reported decision has applied that rule to interest that accrued while a contest was pending. I would not want to be the executor in the case that does, particularly where the executor is also the beneficiary defending the Will and the estate had the cash to make an estimated payment.

Several questions under the statute remain unanswered. It ends the 6% period when “the cause of delay is removed,” and no New Jersey decision says whether that happens: when a settlement is signed, when the court approves it, when judgment is entered, or when the time to appeal runs out. The safest assumption is the earliest of those dates, with the tax paid promptly afterward. The statute also applies the reduced rate where “the decedent’s estate, or a part thereof” cannot be settled, which suggests that the 6% rate may reach only the tax on the disputed part of an estate, though no court has said so. And the statute speaks of “necessary” litigation. Whether a contest the court later finds baseless, or a dispute the fiduciary brought on himself, earns the lower rate is unlitigated, and Heine’s refusal to reward a delay the estate could have avoided suggests the Director would have the better of that argument.

There is no form or published procedure for asking for the 6% rate. In the reported cases the Director applied it on assessment or the Tax Court applied it on review, so the practical course is to tell the Division about the litigation when the return is filed, with the docket number, the date the action was filed, and the date it ended, and to raise the rate on any assessment that charges 10% for the period the estate was in court. It is a small rule, but in a contest over a large taxable share it can be one of the larger numbers on the table.

The Office
12 West Delaware Avenue
Pennington, New Jersey 08534
(609) 730-3838