Backes & Backes (609) 730-3838

Probate Litigation

Notice of probate from a litigator’s perspective

Many of the estate administrations I handle come to me midstream. Many people, when they learn they’re named as executor in a Will, begin the probate process without counsel; I have a lot of respect for people who try to minimize the costs to the Estate by doing the work themselves, and maybe even more for those who know when they’ve done all they can do and need the assistance of a lawyer.

Now, it’s almost always the case that an unrepresented personal representative won’t have done things quite as a lawyer would have, and probably the most common oversight is the notice of probate. In New Jersey, Rule 4:80-6 requires that a personal representative send all beneficiaries and other parties in interest (spouse, heirs, next of kin) written notice that the Will was probated, including the date and place of probate, and stating that a copy of the Will will be provided to them upon request. The notice must be mailed within 60 days after probate, and proof of mailing has to be provided to the Surrogate within ten days after the notice is sent.

More often than not, when I ask a new client who’s serving as personal representative about the notice of probate, the client explains that all the beneficiaries know about the Will already. From a practical point of view, this makes excellent sense; why send formal notice to someone of a fact they already know? From my point of view as an estate litigator, this misses one of the primary functions of the notice of probate. The case In the Matter of Fanny Green, Deceased is one of the things I’m thinking of when I prepare a notice of probate.

Notice of probate protects the Estate and the personal representative from later Estate litigation. Until the notice of probate requirements are met, there can be no confidence that the probate won’t be challenged down the road. In Fanny Green, a beneficiary knew that a Will existed but was not shown to have known its contents or the date of probate, and the court allowed a challenge brought within a reasonable time after he received actual notice, long after it would ordinarily have been barred. A beneficiary who does have actual notice may be held to the deadline even without formal notice, but no executor should want to litigate what a beneficiary knew and when. Notice of probate isn’t merely a nice thing to do; it’s an important part of the personal representative’s duty, and it’s a perilous thing to ignore.

Sidenote: as common as it is for the notice of probate to be overlooked, it is even more common for the proof of mailing requirement to be forgotten. Happily, the case law (some of it unpublished) makes it fairly unlikely that the mere failure to file the proof of mailing will leave the Estate vulnerable. Which is not to say it should be ignored.

The Office
12 West Delaware Avenue
Pennington, New Jersey 08534
(609) 730-3838