Probating an unsigned Will?
The notion that a signature should always be required for certain important documents and instruments continues to fade in New Jersey law, and a Will never signed by the testator can now be admitted to probate.
An unsigned Will comes in under N.J.S.A. 3B:3-3, which is something like a saving provision allowing a Will to be admitted even if it does not meet the requirements for a formal Will or a holographic Will (N.J.S.A. 3B:3-2(a) and (b)). This statute allows for the probate of a document not otherwise qualifying as a Will if the proponent can show by clear and convincing evidence that the decedent intended the document to be a Will.
This rule has been fairly liberally applied, in the interest of equity, and particularly in uncontested matters it can help avoid manifest waste or the thwarting of the decedent’s wishes. For some time the open question was whether the rule is so broad that it would allow the probate of a document, prepared by someone other than the decedent, that the decedent never signed.
The Appellate Division took up the question in IMO Louis Macool, Deceased, 416 N.J. Super. 298 (App. Div. 2010). The facts in Macool aren’t uncommon by any means, except for the moment of the decedent’s death. Ms. Macool met with her lawyer to change her Will, and the attorney thereafter prepared a “rough” draft of the Will, following Ms. Macool’s central instructions and modifying a few small items. Before the draft could be reviewed, Ms. Macool died.
The draft Will in Macool was not admitted to probate. What’s particularly interesting to me are the reasons the draft was rejected. First, the decedent had never seen the Will. In addition, the Will contained some terms that she had never discussed with her attorney, and modified some of the terms she directed. The court held expressly that a writing offered under the statute need not be signed by the testator, and it set out what the proponent must prove:
“We hold that for a writing to be admitted into probate as a will under N.J.S.A. 3B:3-3, the proponent of the writing intended to constitute such a will must prove, by clear and convincing evidence, that: (1) the decedent actually reviewed the document in question; and (2) thereafter gave his or her final assent to it.”
Two years later, the Appellate Division admitted an unsigned copy of a Will to probate under the same statute. In re Estate of Ehrlich, 427 N.J. Super. 64 (App. Div. 2012).
This has pretty significant implications for the practitioner, I think. While it’s not my usual practice to have final estate planning documents reviewed at a separate meeting before signing, there are times when circumstances almost require it. If complex documents need to be reviewed in the evening when witnesses are unavailable, for instance, I may go over the documents, obtain “final assent,” and schedule a short follow-up for the actual signing of the instruments. I suspect that many lawyers send draft copies of Wills to clients for review before meeting. If the client sends back a message saying that the Will is just right and then dies before signing, the draft may be offered for probate. The proponent would still have to prove review and final assent by clear and convincing evidence, in the Superior Court, and nobody should plan on it.
