When a Spouse Dies Mid-Divorce
What happens when a husband or wife dies while their divorce is pending?
The Supreme Court confronted that vexing question in Carr v. Carr, 120 N.J. 336 (1990). Mr. Carr died before the divorce was tried, leaving his estate to the children of an earlier marriage. Mrs. Carr could not receive equitable distribution, because that remedy depended on a judgment of divorce and the divorce action ended with his death. She could not claim the elective share of a surviving spouse either, because the elective share statute excluded a spouse who had been living apart from the decedent under circumstances that would have supported a divorce. The Court called her position a black hole and reached for a constructive trust to keep her out of it. Later cases turned on whether a judge found the circumstances exceptional enough for the same treatment.
The Legislature closed the gap in a law signed on January 8, 2024, and the change reaches the probate statutes as much as the divorce statute. Under N.J.S.A. 3B:5-3(d), a person who is a party to a divorce complaint that has been filed and not dismissed is no longer a “surviving spouse” for purposes of intestacy. Under N.J.S.A. 3B:8-1, the elective share is unavailable once either spouse has such a complaint on file. In exchange, N.J.S.A. 2A:34-23(h)(2) provides that the Family Part’s authority to make equitable distribution does not end when a party dies before final judgment.
For estate work, the amendments move the line from how the spouses were living to whether a complaint is on file. The old elective share test asked about the household, and a spouse who remained in the marital home could keep the right to elect against the Will even after a divorce complaint had been filed. A spouse who is cut out of a Will during a pending divorce, or whose husband or wife dies without one, no longer has a claim in the Probate Part as a surviving spouse. That spouse has an equitable distribution claim in the Family Part, and the executor or administrator will be answering it there.
None of this revises a Will. The statute that revokes gifts to a former spouse, N.J.S.A. 3B:3-14, operates on a divorce or annulment, so a Will that leaves everything to a spouse still says so while the case is pending, and the same is true of beneficiary designations. A person who files for divorce should review those documents with counsel at the outset, within whatever restraints the Family Part has placed on changing them. A complaint that has been dismissed no longer cuts off the surviving spouse’s rights under the probate statutes, which makes the procedural status of the divorce on the date of death the first fact an estate lawyer needs to know.
